So I mentioned yesterday that I’ve been working on a small tech demo in Unity, to help make sure I notice all the difficulties that can come up with Sprite Lamp, and the first one that has presented itself is the issue of animating with multiple (sets of) sprite sheets. A few people asked me about this already but I didn’t quite have my head in the game enough to give good answers. Hopefully now that I’ve played with it a bit more directly, I can do better.
Here’s the script referenced in this post.
Oh and before I go on, a quick annoying reminder that Sprite Lamp is at 30% off on Steam as I write this!
Animations with a single sprite sheet
The simple situation for frame animation in Unity is one big sprite sheet. This is, I suspect, reasonably common – especially with people working with pixel art, and textures going up to 4096×4096. Someone in this situation who wants to use Sprite Lamp is in a pretty easy situation in terms of programming – essentially, everything just works easily. You’ll want to make a sprite sheet of the diffuse channel, cut it up with Unity’s sprite editor, create animations, and apply them to a game object with an animation controller. So far, everything is normal. Then, you’ll want to create a corresponding normal map sprite sheet with Sprite Lamp (either using whatever texture packer tool you want, though be wary of rotating normal maps, or by drawing the lighting profiles in sprite sheet positions then processing them all at once). You don’t need to cut this up into sprites in Unity after you’ve imported it. Then, apply a Sprite Lamp (or other) material to your game object, drag the normal map sprite sheet into the NormalDepth slot, and everything should be fine.
The reason this works smoothly is because if you have one big sprite sheet, all the animation system is changing is the UVs on the sprite, and because the Sprite Lamp shader doesn’t do anything fancy with UVs, it’ll just look up into each sheet in the same spot.
Multiple sprite sheets
This is where things get tricky. The issue is that Unity’s animation controller automatically switches textures as necessary, but it only provides for switching the main texture, because usually you only have one texture when you’re doing this kind of animation. By way of example, say you have a character who can walk or run. If you’re making a normal 2D game without lighting, you might have two textures: WalkSheet, and RunSheet. Ordinarily, when your character is walking around, Unity will be switching between sprites in one sheet, and thus changing the UVs – but when your character switches to running, Unity has to switch to the RunSheet texture, which it does automatically.
Suppose instead though, you are using Sprite Lamp, so you have six textures. WalkSheet, WalkSheet_Normal, WalkSheet_Emissive, RunSheet, RunSheet_Normal, and RunSheet_Emissive. Your character starts walking around fine, with WalkSheet, WalkSheet_Normal, and WalkSheet_Emissive applied – all is well. Then they break into a run though, and we’re screwed. The animation system switches the diffuse texture to RunSheet, but the normal and emissive channels keep the Walk versions. This will look somewhere between pretty broken and horribly broken, depending on whether or not the walk and run sheets have similar layouts.
How to get around this? Well, essentially, I’ve written this script. It’s still not tested all that much, so I haven’t added it to the official Unity pack yet, but it has worked in my use case and will hopefully work in yours (if not, let me know). The script works by creating a dictionary at load time, which uses a texture as its key, to look up the corresponding textures. Then in the update, it will check the object it’s attached to to see if the texture it’s using has changed – if it has, it automatically sets all the other textures.
To use it, the first thing to do is attach it to your character (or whatever). Second, you have to populate some lists – this is currently done manually, but I’m looking into nicer ways to handle this. The lists are ‘primaryTextures’ and ‘otherTextures’. Into ‘primaryTextures’, drag all the sprite sheets that your AnimationController knows about – so in our above example, that would be WalkSheet and RunSheet. In the ‘otherTextures’ list, you’ll want to drag all the auxiliary stuff Sprite Lamp uses – here, that would be ‘WalkSheet_Normal’, ‘WalkSheet_Emissive’, ‘RunSheet_Normal’, and ‘RunSheet_Emissive’. For each element of ‘primaryTextures’, the script will search for any textures in ‘otherTextures’ that are suitably named, and associate them so that they get set at runtime.
That should be just about it! As always with Unity things, if I’ve missed some obvious smarter way to do this, please let me know. Also, I’ll be along soon with a more concrete example of this method that you can download, in case my description here doesn’t make things clear.
Coming up next…
The other problem I rapidly ran into here is the problem of ‘light sources’ that exist in the emissive texture map. They tend to move around within the sprite, and you’ll likely want an actual light source to move with it, but the engine doesn’t know how to move it appropriately. I’m working on a script that will automatically parse an emissive map and approximate clusters of bright pixels by creating a light of the appropriate intensity/colour/position. It’s at proof-of-concept-ish stage now and isn’t ready to distribute just yet, but so far it looks pretty cool, particularly by matching the light’s movement to the animation’s framerate.
